BAD POINTS:
From right to left:
a) That c4d seems to have low quality, or you've sharpened it , it seems pixelated to me, and it's bad to the eye
b) This c4d messes the signature BADLY, I don't think you even tried to blend it to the siggy, it's like she has a pillow made of ruby.
c) I think this is a product of the liquification but its shape is bad and it needs more work to look acceptable - also this black dot on the pink shape makes the situation worse
d) Why would you create this purple ball if you want to cover it with the c4d? Some changes on the blending mode of the ball/c4d could've provided a better result
e) Bad smudging on the light ray, it makes it look unatural
GOOD POINTS:
a) Really nice text, amazing job in it.
b) Nice render
c) Colours match perfectly
d) Nice use of liquify
Rating : 6/10
Comments : The sig was NOT ready! It needed more work and better collaboration, it's noticeable that someone created the sig and then someone else tried to fix it.
From right to left:
BAD POINTS:
a) I can notice a line there , that works like a border which cuts the flow in two, decreases quality
b) Really messy background, makes it difficult to blend with the render
c) DESTRUCTIVE TEXT, really big , really ugly and with a crappy position. If it wasn't the CRISIS logo i'd just delete the image at once.
d) White borders on a dark sig? Bad idea. At least reduce their opacity.
e) The render has suffered an extreme modification especially at the area of the gun , and I believe that's because of the messy background.
GOOD POINTS
a) Really good flow, perfect emphasis on the render and the weapon.
b) Flawless use of c4ds and this sig is an example of how people must use c4ds as an effect
c) Good job with the smuding, saves it up for the messy background
d) No colour dismatch.
Rating: 7/10
Comments : If it wasn't for this ... unacceptable text , it would've been a masterpiece.
WINNER for me : MD & KS
Really close one, but the girls' signature needed more work. It looks professional but with a closer look, it seems rushed.