Its really sad to see that noone realises that a forum is not all about the content, but the comunity and its actions. All I see from the past few years is people hatin on each other. Being in a comunity is about having fun and helping people, but u all do is the exact opposite.
And about redesigning the forum, completely unnecessary imo. If i was at your place I'd do the following things.
1. Instead of wasting money on redesign (why fix something if it aint broken), maybe organise monthly/weeksly ? tournaments on the FOTM games with small prizes.
2. Maybe rent a TS server.
3. Get mods separeted by games, so they can interact better with the comunity and create content like news/events for the given game. Get a section for upcoming games higher up than down at the bottom.
4. Try to think of other ways to unite the comunity. (different activities/events).
5. I just saw, the l2 section is huge and unnecessary, I'd swap that with the LOL section.