the forum is not dead because of the karma system nor are people not sharing because of it...It's simple it's just that the game - Lineage 2 is not as popular as it was back in f.e 2008 when i registered here when everyone was talking about it sharing all sorts of tools for it n sh1t... And since the forum is mainly based on Lineage 2 it's dying along with the game. Anyway your opinion sucks if you really want to stimulate sharing n sh1t just start paying people to do so.. sharing cheats and hacks is stupid and i stopped doing so as soon as i realised it since im sharing cheats n shit so some retard can come up with an antidote for my cheat puts it in a pack and then makes money out of me... I went private and i love it ;].