Ok let's start.
1st) the effect are a bit random there plus that the render is not blended well.It seems so pasted
2nd)Effects are ok but it seems a bit empty to my eyes.Blending is too hard for my eyes and the render is a bit unblended.I would suggest for this (just to test it) one sepia Photo philter 85% destiny gthen apply your image and use Maximum philter at 2 pixels.Then go to fade maximum and set the belnding mode to Mutiny and 30% opacity.
3rd)It's the best till now.Blending are awesome.Same for your flow.Deapth is ok too.Just fix a bit the lighting.
And don't forget to put deapth to your tags.It makes them special.A good way is to select your soft brush set both opacity and fill at 50%.choose b;ack color and dark the edges of your tag.