Well, I really love Lineage 2. <-- By that post, I guess some (if not most) would assume that I would vote for the first option. However, I vote for the second. Why? Simple - because MaxCheaters needs to develop, it needs to go beyond Lineage II. Right now, there area mostly (if not only) Lineage 2 players/creators - whatever you want to call them, so it is obvious that the vote will be in favor of making MxC only L2 forum. Yes, it was nice while Lineage 2 was viral, but now it isn't that 'viral'. Also, I will deny one post that I read here - Lineage 2 is still on-going, active and has a lot of players.
Anyway, my point is: don't make this forum only Lineage 2 Focused, Lineage 2 isn't that viral anymore!! Look up what games (MMOS etc.) are popular, make sections for those games and advertise the forum! Otherwise, you won't really get new members. Maybe a few players or people that want to create a server will register, but they won't really be active.