Well, hello again everybody.

I will show you my second try making a signature with adobe photoshop.

Please rate it with comments + numbers.

Both styles of opinions (bad and good), are welcome.

I'll tell it again, it's my second try, i'm not a pro :P

 

 

v2

 

 

v3

 

 

Avatar

 

 

v2

 

 

Also, can you tell me if I have improved my skills since my first try?

 

Best Regards :D

in my opinion the background colours are completely away from the render... you have to change them to something dark, that fits the render... and next time, try to make the border either white, or black, and you can also add some transparency to make it cooler

 

nice try though

in my opinion the background colours are completely away from the render... you have to change them to something dark, that fits the render... and next time, try to make the border either white, or black, and you can also add some transparency to make it cooler

 

nice try though

totally agree.

you backgrounds colors must to take a gradient map or make a new background.

the red outlines make it white it looks beter.

4/10

OK, I made a second version with changed lighting effects a bit, and turned the red outlines into white.

Is it better?

 

Well the render is a bit ugly and don't match a lot with its background and i dont like the font/color. Anyway nice try 5/10 from me.

Well the render is a bit ugly and don't match a lot with its background and i dont like the font/color. Anyway nice try 5/10 from me.

thats the base think which you take low point results coyote.

Font is kinda shitty, background + render are not looking that similar, background has nothing special but some color changes and waves on it, render is ugly (imo) but still your 2nd try, 6/10!

 

P.s.: I hope you didn't used a tutorial for it.

Font is kinda shitty, background + render are not looking that similar, background has nothing special but some color changes and waves on it, render is ugly (imo) but still your 2nd try, 6/10!

 

P.s.: I hope you didn't used a tutorial for it.

 

Nahh almost all tutorials are for a specified Render + way to make it.

I'm just using my imagination xD

v3 added.

Tell me if it's better than the other two.

It's completely different..

BTW I have learned some new things, so I suppose I'm getting improved..

 

EDIT: v2 for avatar added.

 

Waiting for comments..

Sorry but all of them are rated from me with the same rate:

0.5/10

I know that it sounds harsh but it's the truth!

You gotta improve your skillz dude!When i started my sigs were too ugly.

You have the skills and if you have the patience too you gonna be a good gfx designer!

Just read more guides!

Read about render positioning,color theory,text adding,borders,effects!

I could never imagine Orange with Dark Green,Yellow and Brown but anyway..

 

Soz dude, but you need more imagination ;)

 

Keep practice..

The render is ok.

 

The backround sux cause the colours don't fit.

 

You need to find 2 colours that match so you can get an nice backround without destroying the whole signature with such awful backrounds :)

OK Thank you all guys!

I'll take in mind what you all told me ;)