Well, it was not ideal that the server started with login down and being off for a while, but seems that the team is working to improve the DDOS protection and hopefully this time they will do better. I will not quit but will give it a second chance. So far it seems a server with good features and if the server manage to overcome the problems which every new private server has, then why not staying here.
See for example l2dex. They are so big and what, they got their ass kicked, the server was 5 days off, login completely crashed and they had to restore the database from scratch, then hacked by some guy who gave items, ect. Well if l2dex fails after so many people donating there, I think we should give a chance to this server.
Something I like so far is the attitude of the l2roe stuff. Working to resolve the issues, never been impolite, don't give fake promises. How often you see a good team? From my experience it is kind of rare to find a responsive team, who doesn't threat you as some lowbie.
So your choice, to quit, to stay, to start, but we haven't really seen the server yet as to judge if it is good or bad.